HOME  |  LINKS  |  CONTACT
 

Successful Defense of Wisconsin and Federal Criminal Cases

Madison DWI, DUI, OWI, Drunk Driving Defense lawyer Robert T. Ruth

has successfully defended criminal cases in Wisconsin since 1993.

Call 608-257-2540 for a free consultation.

 

Robert T. Ruth

Criminal Defense Lawyer

(608)257-2540

SE HABLA ESPAÑOL

 
Wisconsin Criminal Defense

Drugs        

Domestic/Battery

Sex Crimes

Homicide

Theft

Fraud

Driving Offenses

Drunk Driving

  

Criminal Appeals

Federal Criminal   Appeals

Wisconsin Criminal Appeals

Federal Criminal Defense

Drugs

Conspiracy

Fraud

Internet/Sex Crimes

Firearms

Target Letter

Grand Jury          Subpoena

Asset Forfeitures

Results

 

 

Madison DUI  Defense Lawyer

The drunk driving laws seem to just get harsher.  Yet, there are still defenses that beat the charge outright or substantially reduce the damage.  My approach to a drunk driving charge is to first evaluate the case for every possible defense.  Was the stop constitutional? Was the arrest constitutional?  Is there evidence to support all of the elements?  Is there a challenge to any prior offense?  If there is a defense, I pursue it vigorously.  If there is no reasonable defense to the charge, however, and unfortunately that is often case, the next step is to work toward minimizing the damages.  Do not be fooled into thinking that the right lawyer will beat any case.  The fact is the vast majority of drunk driving cases end in a guilty or no contest plea.  Nevertheless, there are many approaches to a drunk driving case that substantially reduce the impact of a conviction.

The bottom line is that the only way to find out if your case has a legitimate defense is to have it reviewed by a qualified lawyer.  And, if it turns out that there is no reasonable defense to the charge, a good lawyer is indispensable at settling the case on the best possible terms.

Drunk driving is known by many names.  In Wisconsin, the official name is operating under influence of intoxicant or other drug.  This is commonly abbreviated OWI and PAC.  The PAC stands for prohibited alcohol concentration.  Some individuals refer to the offense as driving while intoxicated or driving while impaired, abbreviated DWI.  Others refer to it as driving under the influence, or DUI.    Do not get hung up on these names, whether you think need an OWI lawyer, a DWI lawyer a DUI lawyer or a drunk driving lawyer, attorney Robert T. Ruth

Drunk driving, also known as OWI, DUI, PAC or DWI, is generally two separate offenses.  It’s like a fishing lure with two hooks.  If they don’t catch you with the first hook, they will try to catch you with the second.  The first offense is operating under the influence of an intoxicant.  For this offense, the bottom line is whether your ability to operate a motor vehicle was impaired by alcohol, drugs or a combination of the two.  The prosecution may use your breath or blood test result to try to prove impairment, but a threshold is not necessary to the charge.  A police officer may conclude that you are too impaired to drive and arrest you for OWI even though you end up below the legal limit. 

The second hook for the prosecution in a drunk driving case is the charge of prohibited alcohol concentration.  For this charge, impairment is not the issue; the issue is strictly the amount of alcohol or restricted controlled substance in your system at the time of the driving.  If you are above the legal limit, it does not matter how well you handle yourself, you will face a charge of operating with a prohibited alcohol concentration.

Do I have to have a blood/breath alcohol content of .08% or more to be charged with drunk driving?

No.  In Wisconsin, what most people call "drunk driving" actually consists of two separate charges, operating while intoxicated (OWI) and operating with a prohibited alcohol concentration (PAC). To be convicted of OWI, the prosecutor must prove that you operated a motor vehicle on a public highway or other prohibited place while "under the influence" of alcohol, drugs or both. A driver is considered "under the influence" when his or her ability to operate a vehicle is "impaired" by alcohol, drugs, or both. Impairment, however, does not necessarily depend on a BAC of .08% or greater. For example, someone who has a
relatively low tolerance for alcohol may suffer impairment with a BAC of .07%.

It is important to remember that the question of impairment depends to a large extent on opinion evidence. The police officer may hold the opinion that your speech is slurred or that your balance is unsteady. And, based on this opinion, the officer may conclude that you are "impaired." You or another witness may hold the opinion that your speech is not slurred, nor your balance unsteady. Remember, the police officer’s opinion is just that, an opinion. The jury makes the final decision about whether there is enough evidence to conclude that you were impaired.

The second "drunk driving" offense in Wisconsin, operating with a prohibited alcohol concentration (PAC), depends entirely on the amount of alcohol in your system (or restricted controlled susbtance) at the time you operated a motor vehicle on a public highway or other prohibited place.

Most police departments test your alcohol content by a breath or blood test. These tests, however, are not perfect. Machines malfunction, officers sometimes fail to correctly administer the test, and external factors may skew the test results. Also, the alcohol tests only claim to measure your breath or blood alcohol concentration at the time of the test. But, alcohol in your system is always changing. The alcohol concentration in your system at the time of the test is not necessarily the same as it was at the time you were driving. You cannot be convicted of a PAC offense unless the prosecutor can prove that you
had a prohibited alcohol concentration or restricted controlled substance in your system at the time you operated a motor vehicle in a prohibited place.

Do I need to "drive" a moving vehicle to be charged with drunk driving?

No.  Wisconsin law prohibits "operating" a motor vehicle while intoxicated or with a prohibited alcohol concentration. "Operate"
generally means to manipulate any of the controls necessary to put the vehicle in motion. So, turning the key in the ignition, even if the car does not move, amounts to operation under Wisconsin’s drunk driving law. However, the question of operation gets tricky, especially if a witness did not observe the vehicle in motion or observe you manipulate the vehicle’s controls. If you have any question about whether your conduct amounts to "operation" as defined by the law, contact attorney Robert T. Ruth.



Can I get charged with drunk driving in a parking lot?

Y
es, however, only in certain parking lots. If you were stopped for drunk driving in any area other than on a public road, you should
contact one of our attorneys to review your situation to determine if you were stopped in a prohibited area.



Can the police stop my car for any reason?

No.  In most cases, to stop your car, the police either need a warrant, or they must have a reasonable suspicion that you committed or
are in the process of committing a criminal or traffic offense. And, in most cases, if they don’t have a warrant or reasonable suspicion, any evidence that was obtained as a result of the illegal stop cannot be used against you. So, even if you were operating under the influence, if the stop of your vehicle was illegal, your case may be dismissed.

Since every case depends on unique facts, it is impractical to list all of the possible reasons why the stop of a vehicle may be illegal. However, if you were charged with drunk driving after the police stopped your vehicle, you should contact attorney Robert T. Ruth to investigate your specific situation.



Can the police require a breath or blood test for any reason?

No.  Under the implied consent law, to demand a breath or blood test, a police officer must have probable cause to believe that you violated one or more driving related offenses and must have arrested you for that offense. In some cases, the police may also force a breath or blood test if they have probable cause to believe that there is evidence of a crime in your blood or breath. However, the area of compelling breath or blood tests is complicated and fact specific. If you submitted to a breath or blood test, or refused to do so, you should contact one of our lawyers to discuss your specific situation.



If I was previously convicted of drunk driving, will a new offense for
drunk driving count as a second offense?


Not necessarily. Beginning January 1, 1999, a second offense is generally defined as any offense that occurs within 10 years of a
previous offense. The 10 years is calculated from the date that the offenses occurred, not the dates of conviction. No offense that
occurred before January 1, 1988 counts as a prior offense.

Additionally, some unconstitutionally obtained convictions do not count as prior drunk driving offenses. So, before you accept a previous OWI conviction as a prior offense, you should have the specific facts of the previous conviction reviewed by a qualified attorney.

Penalties in Wisconsin

There are many intricacies to Wisconsin’s drunk driving penalty structure. So, in any particular case, you should contact a qualified defense attorney to advise you of the possible penalties in your case. Also, the penalties for drunk driving regularly change. The information provided below sets forth a basic outline of the drunk driving penalty structure as of May 2008 for individuals 21 years of age or older.

First Offense

   • Forfeiture of $150-300, plus costs and assessments
  
6-9 month license suspension
  
Mandatory alcohol assessment/driver safety plan
  
Six points assessed against driver’s license
  
Major traffic offense counted against driver’s license
  
Court may order restitution

Second Offense

  
 • Forfeiture of $350-$1,100, plus costs and assessments
  
Imprisonment for not less than 5 days nor more than 6 months
  
12-18 month license revocation
  
60-day to 12 month waiting period to obtain occupational license
  
Mandatory alcohol assessment/driver safety plan
  
Six points assessed against driver’s license
  
Major traffic offense counted against license
    • Court may order restitution

Third Offense

    • Forfeiture of $600-$2,000, plus costs and assessments
  
Imprisonment for not less than 30 days nor more than 1 year
  
24-36 month license revocation
  
90-day to 12 month waiting period to obtain occupational license
  
Mandatory alcohol assessment/driver safety plan
  
Six points assessed against driver’s license
  
Major traffic offense counted against license
  
Seizure and forfeiture of vehicle or ignition interlock device
  
Court may order restitution

Fourth Offense

Forfeiture of $600-$2,000, plus costs and assessments
Imprisonment for not less than 60 days nor more than 1 year
24-36 month license revocation

90-day to 12 month waiting period to obtain occupational license
Mandatory alcohol assessment/driver safety plan
Six points assessed against driver’s license
Major traffic offense counted against license
Mandatory seizure and forfeiture of vehicle

Fifth or Sixth Offense

Forfeiture of $600-$10,000, plus costs and assessments
Imprisonment for not less than 6 months nor more than 6 years
24-36 month license revocation
90-day to 12 month waiting period to obtain occupational license
Mandatory alcohol assessment/driver safety plan
Six points assessed against driver’s license
Major traffic offense counted against license

 


This web site is designed for general information only. The information presented at this site should not be construed to be formal legal advice nor the formation of a lawyer/client relationship.

The material and information contained on these pages and on the pages linked from these pages are intended to provide information and not legal advice. The information presented on these pages may not be applicable to your specific legal or factual situation. The information presented is based on Wisconsin law, and may not be accurate in other states. 

Sending an e-mail or downloading information from this website does not create an attorney-client relationship with our firm.  Remember that electronic mail on the Internet is not secure and, hence, there can be a risk of interception  This website is not intended to be a solicitation in any state where this website fails to comply with all laws and ethical rules of that state. This site is meant to be informational only, consistent with the legal profession's obligation to educate the public.